A Guide from Tiemann Defense | California DUI & Criminal Defense Attorneys
California Criminal Record Cleaning, Arrest Record & Mugshot Removal
A criminal record can follow you long after your case is over. Even when charges were dismissed, a person was acquitted, probation was completed, or a conviction was dismissed, information about an arrest or criminal case may continue to appear online. A Google search of your name may reveal an arrest article, booking photograph, mugshot, court record, background-check website, social-media post, or old news story. For many people, the problem is not simply what appears on their official criminal record. The bigger problem is what a potential employer, landlord, licensing agency, customer, professional organization, or even a date sees when they search their name online.
At Tiemann Defense, we help California clients understand the difference between:
- Legally clearing a criminal record
- Sealing an arrest record
- Dismissing or reducing a conviction
- Removing or suppressing online criminal-record information
- Removing a mugshot from websites
- Removing or suppressing old arrest publications
- Cleaning up search-engine results
These are related but different processes.
Can I Clean My Criminal Record Online?
Sometimes—but an online rehabilitation or reputation-management company cannot legally erase a California criminal record simply because you pay them. There are two separate problems that need to be addressed.
Problem #1: The Official Criminal Record
Your arrest and conviction information may exist in records maintained by courts, law enforcement agencies, and the California Department of Justice. Legal record-clearing may involve remedies such as:
- Arrest record sealing
- Arrest record destruction in appropriate cases
- Dismissal of a conviction
- Felony reduction
- Expungement
- Other statutory record relief
California law provides several different forms of record relief, depending upon what happened in the case. For example, certain arrests that did not result in a conviction may qualify for sealing under Penal Code § 851.91. This can include arrests where charges were never filed, charges were dismissed, diversion was successfully completed, or the defendant was found not guilty. California also provides various forms of automatic record relief. However, an important distinction is that automatic relief does not necessarily mean the information is physically deleted from every government record. The California Department of Justice explains that certain automatic relief results in a notation being added to the criminal-history record rather than simply deleting the arrest or conviction from the DOJ record.
Problem #2: What the Internet Says About You
Even after obtaining legal relief, information may remain on the Internet. For example, you may still find:
- A mugshot
- An arrest article
- A booking photograph
- A local-news story
- A police-blotter publication
- A background-check website
- A commercial criminal-record website
- A social-media post
- An old blog post
- A reposted article
- A cached or indexed search result
A court order does not automatically cause every website on the Internet to delete its copy of the information. That is where online reputation management or rehabilitation companies may sometimes help.
What Is an Online Criminal Record Rehabilitation Company?
An online rehabilitation company—sometimes called an online reputation management company, criminal-record cleanup company, or mugshot removal service—typically focuses on the information that appears when someone searches for your name online. Depending upon the company and the circumstances, its services may include:
- Contacting websites that publish arrest information
- Requesting removal of mugshots
- Requesting correction of inaccurate information
- Requesting removal of outdated content
- Contacting website administrators
- Requesting removal from commercial databases
- Submitting appropriate search-engine removal requests
- Suppressing unfavorable search results
- Promoting favorable or neutral information so negative results appear lower in searches
This is fundamentally different from obtaining legal relief from a California court.
An online reputation company cannot substitute for a California criminal defense attorney when the underlying problem is an official arrest or conviction record.
Step 1: Find Out What Is Actually Online
Before paying an online rehabilitation company, you should determine exactly what information is appearing online. Search your:
- Full name
- Name + city
- Name + arrest
- Name + DUI
- Name + criminal
- Name + mugshot
- Name + booking
- Name + county
- Name + court
Also search Google Images and other major search engines. Make a list of every result that concerns you. For each result, save:
- The website name
- The URL
- A screenshot
- The date you found it
- The information being published
- Whether the information is accurate
- Whether the case was dismissed
- Whether you were convicted
- Whether the conviction was later dismissed
- Whether the arrest has been sealed
This information can help determine what needs to be addressed.
Arrest Records: Can an Arrest Be Removed?
An arrest is not the same thing as a conviction. A person can be arrested and never convicted of a crime. California provides legal remedies for certain arrest records. Depending upon the circumstances, an arrest may be eligible for sealing, and in some circumstances records may be eligible for destruction. California Courts specifically recognizes several situations in which a person may seek to seal an arrest record, including when no charges were filed, charges were dismissed, the person completed qualifying diversion, or the person was found not guilty.
There are also situations involving factual innocence where a court can order arrest records sealed and destroyed.
The important point is this: You generally should address the legal status of the arrest before assuming that an online reputation company can solve the problem. If your arrest is legally eligible for relief, obtaining the appropriate California court order may provide a much stronger foundation for addressing the information that remains online.
What If My Arrest Record Was Already Sealed?
Even if your arrest has been sealed, you may discover that information about the arrest is still online. This can happen because a private website may have obtained the information before the record was sealed. For example, an old news article might continue to exist even after the underlying arrest record has received legal relief. The California Department of Justice explains that sealing and record relief can affect what government agencies may disclose, but this does not necessarily mean every copy of the information maintained elsewhere disappears from the Internet. That is why legal record clearing and online reputation cleanup should be viewed as two separate steps.
Conviction Records: Can a Conviction Be Removed?
A conviction presents a different problem. Depending on the offense, sentence, probation history, and other circumstances, California law may provide a mechanism for obtaining dismissal or other relief. For example, eligible misdemeanor convictions may be dismissed when the applicable requirements are satisfied, including circumstances involving completion of probation and having no new cases pending. Certain felony convictions may also qualify for dismissal or reduction depending upon the circumstances. However, an online reputation company cannot turn a conviction into a non-conviction simply by removing a website from Google. If the goal is to legally improve the underlying criminal record, the appropriate California legal remedy should be evaluated first.
What About a Mugshot?
A mugshot can be one of the most damaging pieces of information to appear online.
A person searching your name may see the booking photograph before seeing anything else about you. Mugshots may appear on:
- Mugshot websites
- News websites
- Blogs
- Social-media pages
- Search-engine image results
- Commercial databases
- Arrest-publication websites
A reputation-management company may be able to contact the website publishing the photograph and request removal. However, there is no guarantee that every website will remove it. The same photograph may have been copied or republished on multiple websites.
This means that removing one mugshot does not necessarily remove every copy of the photograph from the Internet.
What About an Online Arrest Publication?
An arrest may have been reported by a newspaper, television station, online publication, blog, or other website. The publication may remain online for years. If the case was dismissed or you were found not guilty, the continued publication of the original arrest story can be particularly frustrating because someone searching your name may see the arrest without immediately seeing how the case ended. Depending upon the circumstances, possible strategies can include:
- Requesting a correction
If the article contains inaccurate information, a correction may be requested from the publisher.
- Requesting an update
If the article accurately reported the arrest but does not report the final disposition, you may request that the publisher update the story.
- Requesting removal
Some publishers may voluntarily remove older content.
- Search-engine suppression
In some situations, reputation-management professionals may work to reduce the visibility of negative search results.
- Legal remedies
Depending upon the facts, there may be legal issues involving inaccurate information, privacy, defamation, or other claims. These issues should be evaluated by an attorney rather than assuming that an online cleanup company can provide a legal solution.
Can an Online Rehabilitation Company Remove a DUI Arrest or DUI Mugshot?
An online reputation company may be able to help with the online presence of a DUI arrest.
For example, it may attempt to address:
- DUI mugshots
- DUI booking photographs
- DUI arrest articles
- DUI arrest websites
- Online background-check listings
- Search-engine results
But it is important to understand the distinction. An online company does not erase the underlying DUI arrest from the California DMV, California DOJ, court, or law-enforcement records. If you are concerned about the legal consequences of a DUI arrest or conviction, you should first determine whether you qualify for an appropriate form of California record relief.
Then, if unwanted information remains online, you can consider an online reputation-management strategy.
Be Careful Before Paying an Online Criminal Record Cleanup Company
There are many companies offering to “clean,” “erase,” “remove,” or “expunge” criminal records online. Before paying a company, ask exactly what it is promising to do.
Ask these questions:
- Are you removing the government record or only the Internet publication?
- Are you an attorney?
- Will you file anything with the court?
- What California statute provides the legal relief?
- Are you obtaining a court order?
- Are you contacting websites directly?
- Are you requesting removal from search engines?
- What happens if the information is republished?
- Does your fee include follow-up requests?
- Are you guaranteeing removal or merely attempting removal?
- What happens if the website refuses?
These questions can help you understand whether you are purchasing legal record relief, online reputation management, or both.
Don’t Confuse “Expungement” With Internet Removal
One of the most common misunderstandings is believing that an “expungement” automatically removes everything from the Internet. It does not necessarily work that way. California DOJ specifically explains that different forms of record relief have different effects and that certain forms of relief result in a notation rather than physically deleting information from the state’s criminal-history record. Likewise, a private website, newspaper, blog, or social-media account is not necessarily automatically connected to a court’s record-clearing process.
Legal record relief and online reputation cleanup are different jobs.
The Best Strategy May Be a Two-Step Process
For many people, the best approach is to address the problem in two stages.
Step 1: Clean the Legal Record
A California criminal defense attorney can evaluate whether you qualify for:
- Arrest record sealing
- Arrest record destruction
- Factual innocence relief
- Conviction dismissal
- Expungement
- Felony reduction
- Other applicable California record relief
The appropriate remedy depends upon the facts of your case.
Step 2: Clean Up the Internet
After determining the legal status of your record, you can address:
- Mugshots
- Arrest publications
- Online court information
- Background-check websites
- Search-engine results
- Social-media publications
- Other online references
An online reputation-management or rehabilitation company may be useful for this second step.
Why You Should Consider Legal Record Relief Before Online Cleanup
Suppose a website is publishing your mugshot. If you simply pay someone to have the photograph removed, the underlying criminal record may still exist. Another website could publish it again. Alternatively, you may have already been legally entitled to have the arrest sealed, but you never obtained the appropriate relief. That is why the first question should be:
“What can legally be done about my California criminal record?” The second question is:
“What can be done about what appears online?” At Tiemann Defense, we believe clients should understand the difference before spending money on online record-cleanup services.
What Should I Do If My Criminal Record Is Showing Up Online?
If you are concerned about an old California arrest, conviction, mugshot, or online arrest publication, start by determining exactly what exists. Then determine whether you qualify for legal record relief. Once the legal status of your record has been addressed, you can evaluate whether online reputation management, mugshot removal, publication removal, correction requests, or search-result suppression may be appropriate. Do not assume that paying an online rehabilitation company will legally erase your criminal record. The company may be able to help with the Internet—but the court and applicable California law control the legal status of your criminal record.
Tiemann Defense Can Help You Understand Your Record-Clearing Options
At Tiemann Defense, California criminal defense attorney Roland X. Tiemann helps clients understand what can and cannot be done to improve the consequences of an old criminal case.
Our approach is to look at the entire problem:
- What does the government record show?
- What does the court record show?
- Was there an arrest without a conviction?
- Was there a conviction?
- Was the conviction dismissed?
- Can the record be sealed or otherwise receive legal relief?
- Is a mugshot appearing online?
- Is an old arrest article appearing in Google searches?
- Are background-check websites publishing the information?
- What can legally be changed—and what requires online reputation management?
The answers are different for every case.
If your old California criminal case is affecting your employment, professional reputation, housing, licensing, relationships, or ability to move forward, contact Tiemann Defense to discuss your record-clearing options.
Tiemann Defense
California Criminal Defense Attorney
Roland X. Tiemann
916.939.3900
Frequently Asked Questions About Cleaning a Criminal Record Online
Can I clean my criminal record online?
You may be able to address some online information through an online reputation-management or rehabilitation company, but online cleanup is different from obtaining legal relief from a California court. An attorney can determine whether your underlying arrest or conviction qualifies for sealing, dismissal, expungement, reduction, or another form of relief.
Can I remove my California arrest record?
In some circumstances, yes. California provides procedures for sealing certain arrests, particularly arrests that did not result in a conviction. Eligibility depends on the circumstances of the case.
Can I remove my mugshot from Google?
Sometimes the website hosting the mugshot may remove it, and search-engine removal or suppression strategies may be available in certain circumstances. However, removal is not guaranteed, and eliminating one result does not necessarily eliminate every copy.
Can an online rehabilitation company erase my conviction?
Generally, an online reputation company cannot itself erase a California conviction from the official criminal record. Legal relief must come through the applicable California legal process.
My case was dismissed. Why is my mugshot still online?
A dismissal resolves the criminal case, but a private website or news organization may still have a copy of the arrest information or mugshot. Legal record relief and online removal are separate issues.
My conviction was expunged. Why can I still find it online?
Legal record relief does not necessarily cause every private website, news story, database, or social-media post to disappear. Additional online reputation-management efforts may be necessary.
Should I hire an attorney or an online record-cleaning company?
It depends on the problem. If you need legal relief from an arrest or conviction, you should consult a California criminal defense attorney. If the underlying record has already received appropriate legal relief but unwanted information remains online, an online reputation-management company may be able to help address the Internet presence.
Can Tiemann Defense remove my mugshot from the Internet?
Tiemann Defense focuses on California criminal defense and legal record relief. We can evaluate the legal status of your criminal record and explain what legal remedies may be available. Online reputation-management companies may be appropriate for the separate task of addressing private websites and search results.
Can a sealed arrest still appear online?
Yes. Sealing affects the legal availability and disclosure of records, but a private website, old news article, or other Internet publication may still have information that was previously obtained and published. California DOJ explains that the effect of sealing and other forms of record relief varies depending upon the statute involved.
What is the difference between criminal record expungement and online reputation management?
Expungement or other legal record relief addresses the legal record. Online reputation management addresses what people can find about you on the Internet. They are separate problems and may require separate solutions.
